In South Africa v. Israel, the ICJ issued provisional-measures orders, not a final judgment that Israel committed genocide. Those orders addressed urgent protection while the case proceeds. On the merits, the Genocide Convention requires proof of specified acts and the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected national, ethnical, racial or religious group as such.
The January order set interim measures
On 26 January 2024, the Court found prima facie jurisdiction under the Genocide Convention, held that at least some claimed rights were plausible, and identified a real and imminent risk of irreparable prejudice. It ordered Israel to prevent acts within Article II, prevent and punish direct and public incitement, enable urgently needed services and humanitarian assistance, preserve evidence and report on implementation. “Plausible rights” is an interim threshold, not a finding genocide occurred. See the January order and South Africa’s application.
March and May added measures
On 28 March, the Court reaffirmed its earlier measures and ordered steps to ensure, without delay and in full cooperation with the UN, unhindered provision of basic services and humanitarian assistance at scale. On 24 May, it ordered Israel to halt its military offensive and other action in Rafah that could inflict conditions of life capable of bringing about the group’s physical destruction in whole or in part. Read the March order and May order in context. Neither is a final merits judgment.
What a merits finding requires
Article II lists acts such as killing group members and deliberately inflicting destructive conditions of life. Each must be accompanied by intent to destroy the protected group, in whole or in part. The Rome Statute definition reflects those elements. Serious civilian harm or other unlawful conduct alone does not establish specific intent.
South Africa’s application presents its allegations; Israel rejects them and has submitted its response. The ICJ’s interim orders do not resolve the final factual and legal arguments. The ICJ case is between states under a treaty and separate from ICC proceedings against individuals. See how the courts’ proceedings differ.