A building in a city may be attacked only if it qualifies as a military objective under the circumstances at the time. The attacker must distinguish military objectives from civilians and civilian objects, avoid attacks expected to cause excessive incidental harm, and take feasible precautions.
The two-part test for a building
Article 52(2) of Additional Protocol I defines military objectives as objects which, by their nature, location, purpose or use, make an effective contribution to military action and whose destruction, capture or neutralization offers a definite military advantage in the circumstances ruling at the time. Both parts must be met. A building’s appearance, civilian ownership or proximity to a military site does not answer the test by itself.
Article 48 requires parties to distinguish at all times between civilians and combatants, and between civilian objects and military objectives. Article 51 prohibits making civilians the object of attack and prohibits indiscriminate attacks. These rules apply in cities as elsewhere. Read Additional Protocol I, Article 52 and its Article 48 distinction rule.
How proportionality limits an attack
An attack is prohibited if the incidental civilian death, injury or damage expected would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated. This is a decision made before the attack using information reasonably available to those planning or deciding it. The rule is not a numerical exchange rate; it requires assessing the expected civilian effects against the specific military advantage.
The ICRC’s Customary IHL Rule 14 states the same proportionality prohibition. A later casualty count is relevant to understanding what occurred, but it does not alone show what harm was expected beforehand or whether the decision complied with the rule.
Defender violations do not remove attacker duties
International humanitarian law prohibits using civilians to shield military objectives. If an armed group places a command post or weapons in a civilian building, that use may be relevant to whether the building meets the military-objective test. It does not make every nearby building targetable or settle whether the expected harm from a particular attack would be excessive.
For every strike, the attacker must apply the rules to the particular target and circumstances. The related pages explain precautions and warnings, defender duties and protected sites, and how investigators assess an attack.