Before striking in a city, those planning or deciding an attack must do everything feasible to verify the target, choose feasible means and methods that avoid or minimize civilian harm, and refrain from an attack expected to cause excessive incidental harm. They must cancel or suspend an attack if its legal conditions are not met.
Verification, choice and cancellation
Article 57 of Additional Protocol I sets out precautions in attack. It requires effective advance warning of attacks that may affect the civilian population, unless circumstances do not permit. It also requires those planning or deciding an attack to take all feasible precautions in choosing means and methods and to cancel or suspend an attack when it becomes apparent that the target is not a military objective or that the expected harm would be excessive.
Feasible precautions depend on what is practicable in the circumstances, including humanitarian and military considerations. A weapon’s accuracy may reduce risk, but precision alone does not establish that the object is a lawful target or that expected harm is proportionate. See Additional Protocol I, Article 57 and the civilian-protection rules in Article 51.
What an advance warning accomplishes
A warning can alert civilians to danger and give them an opportunity to leave when circumstances permit. To be effective, it must provide usable information in the circumstances. It does not remove civilian protection from people who remain, transfer the attacker’s duties to them, or replace target verification, proportionality or other precautions.
If planners learn that civilians remain in the area, that information must be considered in assessing expected harm. The applicable rule is the Article 57 warning and precaution requirement; a warning is one part of the decision, not a blanket authorization for the attack.
The defender has separate protective duties
Article 58 requires parties, to the maximum extent feasible, to remove civilians under their control from the vicinity of military objectives, avoid locating military objectives within or near densely populated areas, and take other necessary precautions to protect civilians under their control from the dangers of military operations. The ICRC’s Customary IHL Rule 23 addresses locating military objectives away from densely populated areas.
These duties coexist. A defender’s failure to protect civilians does not cancel an attacker’s duties for an individual strike. For the target test and harm assessment, see when a target is lawful; for protected sites, see human-shield rules and hospitals.