International humanitarian law does not create a separate category for tunnels. A tunnel used for military command, weapons storage or movement of fighters may qualify as a military objective if it effectively contributes to military action and its neutralization offers a definite military advantage in the circumstances. Attackers must still assess expected civilian harm and take feasible precautions, including where tunnel entrances or routes lie beneath civilian buildings.
Targeting tunnels under the ordinary rules
Article 52(2) of Additional Protocol I applies the same two-part test to tunnels as to other objects. Their location underground does not automatically make them lawful or unlawful targets. The relevant facts include the tunnel’s actual use, the military advantage expected from neutralizing it, the presence of civilians and civilian infrastructure, and the means available to attack it. The rules of distinction and proportionality apply to the whole attack and its expected effects.
Article 57 requires feasible verification and precautions in attack; Article 58 requires parties, to the maximum extent feasible, to avoid placing military objectives within or near densely populated areas and to protect civilians under their control. These obligations apply independently to each side. Refer to Article 52, Article 57, and Article 58.
When a civilian may be targeted
Civilians may not be made the object of attack. A civilian loses protection against direct attack only “for such time” as the person directly participates in hostilities. The ICRC describes direct participation as conduct intended to directly cause harm to a party to the conflict or directly harm its military operations or capacity. Sporadic participation does not turn a person into a combatant at all times.
The ICRC’s Interpretive Guidance uses “continuous combat function” to identify members of an organized armed group whose ongoing role involves direct participation in hostilities. It is an ICRC interpretive approach; the phrase is not an express treaty test, and application can be disputed. Mere political, financial or general logistical support does not automatically establish direct participation. The ICRC explains the approach in its questions and answers on direct participation and the full Interpretive Guidance.
Uniforms are not the sole criterion for civilian protection. The question is the person’s status and conduct under the applicable conflict classification and law. Commanders must base that judgment on reliable, current information and reassess it when circumstances change. For how a specific military site is established and investigated, see evidence and accountability.