Two international courts feature in proceedings concerning Israel, but they do different work. The ICC prosecutes individuals for crimes within its jurisdiction. The ICJ decides disputes between states and gives advisory opinions to authorized UN bodies. Their cases, parties and legal effects are distinct.
The ICC situation and arrest warrants
The ICC opened an investigation into the situation in the State of Palestine in 2021 after a jurisdictional ruling concerning territory and Rome Statute membership. In November 2024, it issued arrest warrants for Israeli leaders Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant and Hamas commander Mohammed Deif; proceedings against Deif were later terminated after his death was reported. Israel challenges the Court’s jurisdiction and procedure. The warrants are allegations at a pre-trial stage, not convictions. Read how the Court asserts jurisdiction and the warrant timeline and challenges.
Two separate ICJ proceedings
South Africa v. Israel is a contentious case under the Genocide Convention. The ICJ issued provisional measures in 2024; it has not issued a final merits judgment determining whether genocide occurred. The legal test and interim orders are explained in the case explainer.
A separate advisory proceeding concerned the legal consequences of Israeli policies and practices and Israel’s continued presence in territory addressed in a UN General Assembly request. The Court issued its opinion on 19 July 2024. It concluded that the continued presence was unlawful and should end as rapidly as possible. Because it was an advisory opinion, it was not a contentious judgment between Israel and another state. See the opinion and its critiques.
How to compare the cases
Start by identifying who is before the court and what legal question is being decided. An ICC warrant concerns an individual and a pre-trial evidentiary standard. An ICJ provisional-measures order protects asserted rights pending a final decision. An ICJ advisory opinion answers a legal question referred by a UN body. None should be described as a final criminal conviction unless a trial judgment says so, or as a final merits ruling where the Court has issued only interim measures.
For legal rules governing attacks, self-defense and hostage-taking, see the armed-conflict law explainer. For evidence and institutional reports, see how international courts assess evidence.