1 min read

The ICJ’s 2024 Advisory Opinion: Findings and Legal Critiques

On 19 July 2024 the ICJ found Israel’s continued presence in the territory it considered unlawful and said it must end as rapidly as possible. Judge Sebutinde dissented, emphasizing security, negotiations and limits of the Court’s approach.

Miriam Bernstein

Miriam Bernstein is the pen name of Hasbara’s Resources desk. Articles on this desk are written and published automatically by artificial intelligence, with no person reviewing them before publication.

On 19 July 2024, the ICJ issued an advisory opinion on legal consequences arising from Israel’s policies and practices and its continued presence in territory covered by the General Assembly request. The Court concluded that the continued presence was unlawful and must end “as rapidly as possible.” This was an advisory opinion, not a contentious judgment between Israel and another state.

The majority’s stated conclusions

The Court reasoned that Israel’s policies and practices obstruct the Arab people’s right to self-determination and that its assertion of sovereignty over parts of the territory violated the prohibition on acquiring territory by force. The opinion calls for an end to the presence as rapidly as possible, cessation of new construction in Israeli communities, evacuation of Israeli residents and reparation for damage. Its grounds and remedies appear in the official opinion.

Judge Sebutinde’s dissent

Vice-President Julia Sebutinde dissented. She argued that the majority’s analysis did not give sufficient weight to the security context, negotiated framework and limits of advisory proceedings. Her dissenting opinion addresses Oslo and the relationship between legal frameworks. These criticisms do not alter the opinion’s holding.

Oslo II established interim arrangements and reserved permanent-status questions for negotiation. The majority concluded those agreements did not override self-determination or validate the presence it found unlawful. The operative phrase is “as rapidly as possible”; the Court did not set a calendar date. See the full opinion.

Advisory status and legal effect

The General Assembly requested legal advice. Advisory opinions carry legal authority and practical weight, while their formal effect differs from a judgment in a contentious case. This opinion is separate from South Africa v. Israel and the ICC’s criminal proceedings. Compare the guide to the proceedings.

Sources

  1. 1.https://api.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/186/186-20240719-adv-01-00-en.pdf
  2. 2.https://api.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/186/186-20240719-pre-01-00-en.pdf

Accessibility

These settings are saved on this device.

Preview

Read clearly, your way

Adjust this page while you read. Explore resources

Text
Text sizeApplies across the site.
Colour and contrast
Theme
Motion
AnimationsMatch device follows your reduced motion setting.