The ICJ and ICC evaluate material under their rules and the question before them. Documents, testimony, expert material, reports and party submissions may enter a record, but their inclusion does not mean judges accept every assertion in them.
The ICJ assesses the record for the issue before it
The ICJ receives pleadings, documents and oral submissions, then assesses them in light of the parties’ arguments and legal issue. At the provisional-measures stage, it considers whether interim protection is warranted; that is not a final factual judgment. In January 2024, the Court assessed claimed rights, urgency and risk of irreparable prejudice in South Africa v. Israel. Read the January order alongside South Africa’s application to distinguish judicial findings from allegations.
The ICC separates warrants from trial proof
At trial, Article 69 of the Rome Statute governs evidence, including witness testimony and the Court’s authority to rule on relevance and admissibility. A warrant uses an earlier threshold: reasonable grounds to believe the person committed alleged crimes. A prosecutor’s application or warrant does not establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Read Article 69 and the Statute’s rules.
Questions that help evaluate a report
Check who gathered information, when and where it was collected, the method used, whether the author had direct access, whether underlying material is available and whether independent material corroborates it. Separate documented facts from legal characterizations and recommendations. Distinguish a party’s filing from a court’s finding. Claims about affiliations or funding require specific evidence and attribution; receipt of material by a court does not validate unrelated claims about its author.
Apply the same questions to evidence offered for or against Israel. A procedural order, advocacy submission and final merits decision carry different weight. For an example of an interim threshold, see the ICJ case explainer.