2 min read

The Override Clause: Could a Knesset Majority Overrule the Supreme Court?

A March 2023 bill proposed that 61 MKs could shield a law from review or reenact one struck down by the Supreme Court. Canada's notwithstanding clause applies to specified rights and expires after five years.

Miriam Bernstein

Miriam Bernstein is the pen name of Hasbara’s Resources desk. Articles on this desk are written and published automatically by artificial intelligence, with no person reviewing them before publication.

A bill that passed its first reading on March 14, 2023, proposed letting 61 of the Knesset's 120 members shield legislation from judicial review or reenact a law after the Supreme Court struck it down. The bill did not become law. Canada's notwithstanding clause is narrower in scope and duration.

The March bill's proposed power

The March bill paired two changes. It would have limited the Supreme Court's power to strike down legislation to a full panel of 15 justices and a four-fifths majority. It also proposed an override declaration: 61 MKs could protect a law in advance or reenact one following a court ruling. The first-reading vote was 61–52. The Israel Democracy Institute's March bill explainer describes its threshold and reach.

How Canada's clause differs

Section 33 of Canada's Charter allows Parliament or a provincial legislature to declare expressly that a law operates despite section 2 or sections 7 through 15 of the Charter. Such a declaration expires after five years, though the legislature may reenact it. The official Constitution Acts text sets out these limits. The proposed Israeli mechanism would have applied across a broader field of Basic Laws and included an advance shield; the March proposal did not include a comparable five-year sunset.

The comparison also has a different constitutional setting. Canada is a federation with a written Charter and provincial legislatures. Israel's proposal concerned the national Knesset and Basic Laws. The differences in rights covered, timing, and duration matter when comparing the two mechanisms. The bill analysis sets out the Israeli proposal alongside the Canadian comparison.

The limited override already in Israeli law

Israel already had a narrow override provision in section 8 of the Basic Law protecting the right to choose a profession. It applied only to laws that expressly stated they operated notwithstanding that Basic Law, required a majority of Knesset members, and normally expired after four years unless a shorter period was set. It did not authorize overriding any Basic Law or Supreme Court ruling generally. The Israel Democracy Institute's account of the existing clause explains its restricted scope.

The March proposal therefore represented a substantial expansion from a right-specific mechanism to a broad power affecting judicial review. The proposal's first-reading passage did not enact that power.

Sources

  1. 1.https://en.idi.org.il/articles/46387
  2. 2.https://en.idi.org.il/articles/23521
  3. 3.https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/const/fulltext.html

Accessibility

These settings are saved on this device.

Preview

Read clearly, your way

Adjust this page while you read. Explore resources

Text
Text sizeApplies across the site.
Colour and contrast
Theme
Motion
AnimationsMatch device follows your reduced motion setting.