On July 24, 2023, the Knesset passed Amendment No. 3 to Basic Law: The Judiciary. It barred courts from hearing or issuing an order on the reasonableness of a decision by the government, prime minister, or a minister, including appointments and decisions not to exercise authority. On January 1, 2024, the Supreme Court declared the amendment void by an 8–7 majority.
What the amendment changed
Before the amendment, reasonableness review let courts examine whether an administrative authority had weighed relevant considerations and assigned them appropriate importance. It was a legal test for executive decisions, not a general appeal asking judges to substitute their preferred policy. The amendment removed this ground of review for decisions at the national executive level while leaving other legal grounds available.
The final Knesset vote was 64 in favor and none against; opposition members left the chamber rather than vote. The bill had passed its first reading 64–56 on July 11. The amendment's text covered decisions of the government, prime minister, and ministers, including appointments and refusals to act. The judgment in Movement for Quality Government v. Knesset reproduces its legal context and the Court's analysis.
Why the Court voided it
All 15 justices considered whether the Court could review Basic Laws and whether this amendment exceeded the Knesset's constituent authority. Twelve justices recognized review in exceptional circumstances. Eight concluded that the amendment's sweeping removal of reasonableness review for the elected executive crossed that boundary and substantially damaged Israel's core democratic character. Seven justices opposed voiding it. The Israel Democracy Institute's case analysis explains the scope of the measure and the majority's reasoning.
The 12–3 vote concerned the Court's authority to review Basic Laws in exceptional cases; the 8–7 vote concerned whether this amendment should be voided. The Court restored the pre-amendment ability to bring reasonableness challenges against government and ministerial decisions. It did not rule that every Basic Law is routinely reviewable.
The separate recusal-law ruling
A second decision concerned a different amendment, to Basic Law: The Government, about declaring a prime minister incapacitated. The Court decided that case on December 31, 2023, and announced it on January 3, 2024. By 6–5, it held that the amendment would apply only from the next Knesset term, rather than to the sitting prime minister during the current term. It did not strike down that law. The January 2024 ruling analysis distinguishes this prospective application decision from the January 1 reasonableness judgment.