Israel’s 2015 natural gas framework set conditions for developing major offshore fields, restructuring ownership, supplying the domestic market and exporting gas. Its central legal test was a ten-year regulatory stability clause. In March 2016, the High Court of Justice held that the clause could not stand because it bound future governments and constrained the legislature. The translated Supreme Court decision summarizes the ruling.
What the framework covered
The government’s outline addressed field development, ownership of interests in multiple reserves, domestic supply, export limits and competition rules. It sought to establish conditions for long-term offshore investment while setting rules for how gas could be sold and exported. The dispute focused on whether the government could promise stability in areas including taxation, competition and export caps for ten years.
Why the stability clause failed
In Movement for Quality Government v. Prime Minister, HCJ 4374/15, the five-justice panel ruled on March 27, 2016. Four justices found the stability clause invalid; Justice Noam Sohlberg dissented. The majority said the clause restricted the government’s legal discretion and also constrained the legislature. The ruling concerned the clause, rather than a finding that natural gas development itself was unlawful.
Several justices would have annulled the whole outline if the state failed to correct the problem within a year, while Justice Esther Hayut favored striking the stability clause alone. The state then revised the arrangement in May 2016. The government’s decision record documents the subsequent action.
The decision established that a government could not bind its successors and the Knesset against future changes through this stability promise. It left development and regulation to proceed under the revised arrangement and applicable law. See the fields covered by the framework.