Before political Zionism took organized form in the late nineteenth century, Sephardic rabbis Yehuda Alkalai and Yehuda Bibas argued that Jews should take practical steps toward life in the Land of Israel. Their proposals connected religious ideas of redemption with immigration, communal organization, and material support for Jews already living there.
Alkalai proposed collective preparation
Yehuda Alkalai was born in Sarajevo in 1798 and served as a rabbi in Zemun, near Belgrade. In Minhat Yehuda (1843) and other writings, he advocated a representative assembly of Jewish notables that would appeal for a Jewish return and organize gradual migration and community building using communal funds. He also urged Hebrew’s use as a shared national language. The biography of Alkalai summarizes those proposals and his earlier call to support Jews in Jerusalem.
Alkalai’s thinking sharpened after the 1840 Damascus affair, when a blood libel accusation targeted Jews and European Jewish leaders intervened. He treated Jewish collective action as a practical step toward redemption, not as a substitute for religious belief. The scholarly study of the heralds of Zionism discusses Alkalai’s call for immigration and cultivation and Bibas’s emphasis on practical action.
Bibas also linked faith and action
Yehuda Bibas, a rabbi in Corfu in the first half of the nineteenth century, likewise urged Jews to strengthen themselves and prepare for return to the Land of Israel. His arguments appeared in a wider conversation among Jewish religious leaders about redemption, migration, and communal responsibility. A historical account of Alkalai and Bibas describes their reported meeting in 1839; Alkalai had already begun publishing his ideas earlier in the decade.
Neither rabbi led a unified political movement, and their proposals did not alone produce Herzl’s later organization. They were part of several religious and political currents that preceded modern Zionism. For one example of much later immigration from Middle Eastern Jewish communities, see Sephardic and Mizrahi immigration to Israel.