Urban combat does not suspend the laws of armed conflict. Parties must distinguish civilians and civilian objects from military objectives, avoid attacks expected to cause excessive incidental civilian harm, and take feasible precautions to reduce that harm. These duties apply to each attack, including when fighting takes place among buildings and civilian infrastructure.The ICRC conduct-of-hostilities guidance sets out these rules for all parties to a conflict.
What proportionality means
Proportionality does not compare civilian harm with the war’s overall goal. It prohibits an attack expected to cause incidental civilian death, injury, or damage that would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated. The attacker must also take feasible precautions, including choosing means and timing that reduce civilian risk, verifying the target, and canceling or suspending an attack if the legal conditions are not met. ICRC explanation of conduct-of-hostilities rules.
Warnings and evacuation instructions
A warning may help civilians leave an area before an attack, but it is only one precaution. It does not turn civilians who remain into lawful targets, and it does not remove the duty to assess expected incidental harm. The attacking force must still distinguish the target, weigh the anticipated military advantage against expected civilian harm, and take feasible steps to limit danger.
Hospitals and medical units
Medical facilities must be respected and protected while they carry out their medical function. A hospital can lose its special protection only under defined conditions if used, outside its humanitarian function, to commit acts harmful to the enemy; where required, a warning and reasonable time to comply must be given. Even then, the rules of distinction, proportionality, and precautions continue to apply. The ICRC’s hospital guidance explains these conditions.
Evidence that Hamas used a civilian site for military activity can make the site militarily relevant, but the lawfulness of a particular strike depends on the facts and information available at that time. See the specific IDF-reported tunnel case.