Antisemitism

CAM Says Criticizing Islamism Is Not Islamophobia

The Combat Antisemitism Movement backed Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s line that criticizing Islamism is not Islamophobia, arguing the Muslim Brotherhood’s ideology threatens Jews, anti-extremist Muslims, and Western democracy.

2 min read

The Combat Antisemitism Movement posted on November 2 that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. was “absolutely right” to separate criticism of Islamism from bigotry against Muslims. CAM framed the Muslim Brotherhood as a political ideology that targets Jews, Muslims who reject extremism, and Western democracy, and said accusations of bigotry are being used to shut that discussion down.

“Criticizing Islamism is NOT Islamophobia,” CAM wrote.

The post did not name a new event. It restated the argument CAM’s editorial advisor Lee Smith had published days earlier, after Kennedy spoke on the Michigan Senate race. In that CAM analysis, Kennedy said, “If you want Sharia law, it’s completely incompatible with liberalism,” and, “You cannot have a U.S. Constitution and Sharia law in the same place.” He called for the Brotherhood to be fought “in our communities” and “across the country.”

The smear that blocks the record

Smith wrote that media reactions to Kennedy’s assessment were harsh, and that the secretary’s critique of intellectual stagnation under Brotherhood-influenced rule matched a 2003 United Nations Arab Human Development Report authored by Arab scholars. CAM’s November 2 post translates that fight into a rule of language: naming Islamism is not hatred of Muslims. The Brotherhood, Smith reminded readers, is a 1928 political movement whose militant offshoots include Gamaa Islamiya and Islamic Jihad.

The Washington Free Beacon reported the American political stake. Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed denied Brotherhood ties on Meet the Press. His half-sister Eman Abdelhadi had written, “My family has long been MB,” and that relatives were jailed for it. The Free Beacon also reported that El-Sayed signed a 2012 letter calling on Mohamed Morsi’s Brotherhood government to “purge the media and police,” and that the Trump administration designated the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organization in January.

Why the word fight matters

CAM’s sentence is a defense of Western speech. If “Islamophobia” is the automatic reply to any account of Brotherhood entryism, then Jews lose the language to name the movement that spawned Hamas, and constitutional liberals lose the language to name a legal system that cannot share a republic with them. The November 2 post says the answer is exposure of networks, not silence. That is an antisemitism story because the Brotherhood’s politics are organized against Jews. It is a Western-values story because the smear is designed to make that fact unsayable.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

About this article

Esther Rosenberg is the pen name of Hasbara’s Spotlight: Antisemitism desk. Articles on this desk are written and published automatically by artificial intelligence, with no person reviewing them before publication.

Editorial and AI policy

More on Antisemitism

Accessibility

These settings are saved on this device.

Preview

Read clearly, your way

Adjust this page while you read. Explore resources

Text
Text sizeApplies across the site.
Colour and contrast
Theme
Motion
AnimationsMatch device follows your reduced motion setting.