Two Jerusalem religious institutions were attacked six years apart. On March 6, 2008, a gunman killed eight students at Mercaz HaRav yeshiva before an off-duty Israel Defense Forces officer stopped him. On November 18, 2014, two attackers entered a Har Nof synagogue during morning prayers and killed six people, including a police officer.
Eight students were murdered at Mercaz HaRav
The 2008 attack began at 8:36 p.m. when Alaa Abu Dhaim entered Mercaz HaRav, a yeshiva in Jerusalem, and opened fire on students. Eight students were killed and eleven wounded. The victims ranged in age from 15 to 26. Off-duty IDF Captain David Shapira shot and killed the gunman, ending the attack about twenty minutes after it began.
Hamas praised the attack, and some associated accounts later claimed responsibility, but no evidence in the sources used here establishes Hamas as the organizer. The gunman was an individual attacker. That is distinct from the later Har Nof assault, whose perpetrators were a pair of assailants. The Jewish Virtual Library’s account documents the timeline, victims and intervention that ended the shooting. The Israeli government’s report on terrorism focused on Jerusalem discussed the massacre within the city’s security picture.
Har Nof worshippers were attacked in 2014
On the morning of November 18, 2014, two attackers from eastern Jerusalem entered Kehillat Bnei Zion synagogue in Har Nof with firearms and butcher knives. They attacked worshippers during prayer. Six people ultimately died: four civilians and Israel Police Master Sergeant Zidan Saif. Rabbi Haim Rothman, critically wounded in the attack, died of his injuries in October 2015.
The Shin Bet’s annual summary initially recorded five deaths, four civilians and one police officer, with other victims injured. The final toll rose to six when Rothman later died. Hamas spokesmen praised the massacre and urged further attacks, according to the IDF’s account. That public endorsement is documented; it does not establish that Hamas directed the pair who carried out the assault. The 2014 Shin Bet annual report records the initial casualty count and locates the attack in Har Nof.
What links the attacks
Both attackers chose places of Jewish study and worship and targeted civilians. Mercaz HaRav was attacked by one gunman, stopped by an off-duty officer who was nearby. Har Nof was attacked by two armed men during synagogue prayer, and police engaged them at the scene. The Mercaz HaRav account lists all eight students killed; the IDF report describes the Har Nof attack and the praise it received from Hamas leaders.
These attacks also mark different stages in Jerusalem’s terror history. The 2008 yeshiva shooting took place amid continuing violence after the Second Arab terror campaign. The Har Nof massacre occurred in a year when Jerusalem also suffered lethal vehicle attacks. In 2015, attacks increasingly took the form of stabbings and vehicle assaults by individuals; see the 2015 wave for its tactics and context.
Later victim accounting explains the difference between early and final figures for Har Nof. The Shin Bet summary was issued in the aftermath and counted five victims, including the police officer. Rothman survived with critical injuries, remained in a coma and died almost a year later. Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs memorial entry records his death and the completed toll of six. This is why the later total includes five people killed on the day and one who died from his wounds afterward.