No. Jerusalem’s neighborhoods and population changed over centuries, and the modern division between eastern and western Jerusalem dates from the mid-twentieth century. Jewish communities lived in the city before that division, while Arab residents also formed a longstanding and substantial part of Jerusalem.
British census data give a clear snapshot before the city was divided. In 1922 the census counted 33,971 Jews, 13,413 Muslims, and 14,699 Christians in Jerusalem. In 1931 it counted 51,222 Jews, 19,894 Muslims, and 19,335 Christians. The figures cover the municipal city at that time; they are not a census of today’s eastern Jerusalem boundaries. The records are available in the 1922 census and 1931 census.
“Eastern Jerusalem” is a modern label
The term “eastern Jerusalem” usually refers to neighborhoods that came under Jordanian control after the 1948 war and came under Israeli administration in 1967. The label describes a modern geographic and political division; it does not prove that the area had one population or identity throughout history. Before 1948, Jerusalem’s urban life extended across what later became distinct sectors. Its communities included Jews, Muslims, and Christians. Political boundaries shifted, but they did not erase older neighborhoods, cemeteries, houses of worship, or family ties linking residents to different parts of the city.
Jewish history is visible in the southern part of the city as well as in the Old City and other neighborhoods. The Israel Antiquities Authority has reported a Hebrew inscription linked to a Jewish neighborhood in southern Jerusalem during the early Islamic period, between the seventh and eleventh centuries CE. The archaeological account places the neighborhood between the Temple Mount and the Shiloah Pool. See the Authority’s Giv‘ati excavation report.
Communities changed, but Jewish ties endured
Jerusalem’s population was shaped by imperial rule, migration, religious pilgrimage, economic change, and conflict. Jews maintained a presence through successive eras, even when political authorities controlled where they could live or pray. Christian and Muslim communities likewise built institutions and neighborhoods that remain part of the city’s history.
Modern census totals need careful interpretation. The 1922 and 1931 censuses refer to the city’s boundaries at those dates, which differ from later municipal limits. British officials’ 1946 estimate recorded 99,320 Jews, 33,680 Muslims, and 31,350 Christians in Jerusalem. The estimate is reproduced in a UN historical report. These records refute the idea that Jerusalem before 1948 was an exclusively Arab city, while preserving the fact that Arab residents were an established part of it.
These snapshots also help explain why claims about the city’s past need specific dates. Population totals describe residents within the survey boundary; they do not measure religious attachment, ownership, or the full history of nearby villages that later entered the municipality. Keeping those distinctions clear lets the census illuminate the city without asking it to answer a different question.
What the claim leaves out
Calling eastern Jerusalem “always Arab” turns a layered urban history into a claim of permanent exclusivity. The evidence shows changing populations and boundaries, alongside longstanding Jewish, Muslim, and Christian communities. A more accurate account identifies the period and neighborhood under discussion, then uses records from that period rather than projecting today’s divisions backward.
For more on the city’s history and administration, see Jerusalem from 1949 to 1967.