The claim that Israel’s Mossad secretly created and directed the Islamic State (ISIS) to wage war on Muslim nations is a conspiracy theory, not an account supported by the group’s documented history. The Congressional Research Service traces ISIS’s organizational roots to jihadist groups led by Abu Musab al-Zarqawi in Iraq, followed by al-Qaeda in Iraq and the Islamic State of Iraq. No credible evidence cited for the Mossad allegation demonstrates that Israel founded or commanded those organizations.
The group’s documented roots are in Zarqawi’s network
The Congressional Research Service traces the Islamic State’s ideological and organizational roots to forces built and led by al-Zarqawi in Iraq from 2002 to 2006. These included Tawhid wal Jihad and al-Qaeda in Iraq. After al-Zarqawi was killed in a U.S. airstrike in 2006, the organization continued under successor leaders and took the name Islamic State of Iraq.
The Council on Foreign Relations gives the same broad lineage: al-Zarqawi’s militant group aligned with al-Qaeda after the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq, becoming al-Qaeda in Iraq. Successors later renamed the organization the Islamic State of Iraq, then the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria. This history describes an evolving jihadist organization built by its own leaders from predecessor groups. It does not support the claim that Mossad secretly created it.
ISIS expanded during the conflicts in Iraq and Syria. The CRS account says the Islamic State of Iraq rebuilt its capabilities from 2010 under Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi and other leaders. In April 2013, Baghdadi announced a merger with the Syria-based al-Qaeda affiliate Jabhat al-Nusra, using the name Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant. Al-Qaeda leaders rejected the merger. That public split reflected competition and conflict among jihadist groups, not evidence of Israeli direction.
How the conspiracy narrative spread
Claims that ISIS was an Israeli or American project circulated as the group seized territory and drew international attention in 2014. TIME reported that Iran’s English-language Tehran Times framed ISIS’s advance as a U.S.-backed plot and quoted Iranian military chief Hassan Firoozabadi calling the group an Israeli and American movement. TIME contrasted that political accusation with ISIS’s roots in local jihadist groups, al-Qaeda and the conflicts in Iraq and Syria.
The allegation has since resurfaced in social-media conspiracy narratives. The Anti-Defamation League documented posts repeating the false “Israel is ISIS” narrative after the 2024 Crocus City Hall attack, including an account that also claimed Mossad was affiliated with the Islamic State. The Ukraine Fact Check likewise described claims that the CIA and Mossad created ISIS as disinformation and noted their use to attack Western support for Ukraine. These examples show the allegation’s recurring political uses; repetition does not turn it into evidence.
What the record does and does not establish
Historical records can establish an organization’s documented leaders, predecessor groups, alliances and declared name changes. Here, the available accounts trace ISIS through al-Zarqawi’s movement, al-Qaeda in Iraq and the Islamic State of Iraq, followed by Baghdadi’s expansion into Syria. The records place the organization inside the history of jihadist movements and regional conflicts.
They do not make every covert contact or intelligence operation publicly knowable. But the burden rests on the person making the specific claim that Mossad created and directed ISIS. The theory has no verifiable orders, financial records, communications, firsthand testimony or other evidence establishing Israeli command. A claim about a hidden intelligence operation cannot be proved merely by pointing to the fact that a terrorist organization harmed Israel or other regional states.
ISIS was a brutal jihadist organization that killed civilians, seized territory and fought other armed groups, including al-Qaeda affiliates. Its own documented organizational development explains its emergence without inventing an Israeli sponsor. The assertion that Mossad built and directed it remains unsupported, while the recorded lineage points to al-Zarqawi’s network and its successor organizations.