A photograph recirculated with the claim that Israeli citizens were violently pulling apart an Arab child actually shows adults trying to stop border police from arresting a fellow adult during a 2009 clash near Havat Gilad. The image is genuine, but its date, setting and subject were stripped away. AFP’s image archive and the photographer identify what the photograph depicts; its caption does not show a child or an assault on one.
The image predates the viral caption by nearly 15 years
The false caption spread on social media in June 2024. The Check Your Fact report recorded an X post dated June 26, 2024, whose text described the people in the image as trying to tear a child apart. The outlet said that post had been viewed more than one million times. The Quint separately documented the image circulating with a similar caption and said one post had drawn more than 300,000 views when its report was prepared on June 28, 2024. Those are snapshots of separate posts, not a count of everyone who saw the image.
Both reports trace the photograph to Getty Images, where it appeared in September 2009. That chronology alone rules out descriptions of it as a photograph of a recent incident. More decisive evidence comes from the original image record: it supplies a date, a location, a photographer and a caption describing the people and the action. The image was made on September 13, 2009, long before the viral caption appeared.
What the original photograph records
AFP’s fact-check identifies the photographer as Yehuda Raizner and locates the scene at Havat Gilad, near Nablus. Its AFP Fact Check report reproduces the archive caption: the people in the image are pulling a fellow adult as border policemen drag him away during a clash. Police had intervened after trying to confiscate a truck carrying material to build a new house. The scene is therefore a confrontation involving police and adults at a particular place and time, not an attack on a child.
Raizner confirmed the photograph’s meaning directly to AFP. He said the person was an adult whom police were trying to arrest, while friends tried to prevent the arrest. AFP also describes related photographs Raizner took during the same clash and compares the circulated image with archived versions. That comparison matters because a caption can be changed while the underlying photograph remains authentic. Here, archive provenance and the photographer’s account independently fit the visible scene.
The Quint likewise found the image in Getty’s collection and noted that its caption dated it to September 2009. Check Your Fact also reported that Getty’s caption identifies a fellow adult being pulled from border police. These reports did not rely on the viral wording to establish what happened: they checked the image against its earlier publication and caption. AFP adds the photographer’s own confirmation and details the police action connected with the scene.
How the false claim changes the scene
The photograph’s dramatic composition makes it easy to misread without its original caption: several people hold a person who is suspended above the ground, while a uniformed officer stands nearby. But visual appearance cannot establish the person’s age or the reason for the struggle. The original caption and photographer’s account supply those details. They identify an adult being taken by police and friends trying to stop the arrest. The viral wording instead presents the image as proof of a violent act against a child. That is a different event, and the photograph does not support it.
The distinction is precise. The archive does document a physical struggle: police were dragging a man away, and others pulled at him. It does not document a child, an attempt to tear a child apart, or the recent episode implied by posts shared in 2024. Correcting the false caption does not require claiming that every action in the 2009 clash was peaceful. It requires identifying what this particular photograph actually records and refusing to use it as evidence of an unrelated crime.
The image’s recirculation also shows why date and provenance matter when a photograph is used to make a grave accusation. Getty’s dated archive, AFP’s comparison and Raizner’s account converge on the same basic facts: the image was taken in 2009, at Havat Gilad, and depicts adults intervening as border police arrested a fellow adult. The child-abuse caption is false. It converts an old police confrontation into a fabricated attack on a child and should not be shared as a factual description of the photograph.