A photograph of seven-year-old Faid Samim in a Sanaa hospital was recirculated on X in March 2024 with a caption implying it showed a child in Gaza. The image was taken in Yemen on December 28, 2020, and published in January 2021; it does not document conditions in Gaza in 2024. The date matters: the image predates the event it was used to illustrate by more than three years.
What the photograph shows
The media fact-checking organization Kashif traced the image to a Reuters photograph by Khaled Abdullah. Its English-language review identifies the child as Faid Sameem, age seven, at the Seventy Hospital in Sanaa, and gives the photograph date as December 28, 2020. Kashif’s Arabic-language review of the same image and repost reaches the same identification: Faid Samim, a Yemeni child treated for malnutrition and cerebral palsy at Al-Sabeen Hospital in Sanaa.
The image’s original caption supplies details that can be checked against later publication. The Star published the Reuters report on January 4, 2021, with the photograph caption identifying Faid, the hospital ward and Sanaa, Yemen, and crediting photographer Khaled Abdullah. The report describes Faid as seven years old, severely malnourished and living with cerebral palsy. Its caption dates the photograph to December 28, 2020. These location, identity and date details align with Kashif’s tracing.
How the miscaption spread
Kashif reports that X accounts circulated the image with wording that presented it as a picture of hunger in Gaza. Its English review records the caption, “Gaza is dying of hunger, O Muslims,” while the Arabic review describes the same framing. The caption attached a current location and crisis to an older photograph from another country. That is a false identification even though the photograph itself is genuine and depicts a real child who was seriously ill.
The date in this pack’s claim also needs correction. The image was not taken in Yemen in 2019. The Reuters caption reproduced by The Star dates it to December 28, 2020; Kashif says it was published on January 4, 2021. The wider Yemeni humanitarian crisis was ongoing during this period, but a general reference to that crisis cannot replace the date of the specific photograph. The verifiable image record places Faid in Sanaa at the end of 2020.
The account in The Star adds direct medical context: Faid had cerebral palsy as well as severe malnutrition, and a doctor at Al-Sabeen Hospital said he began improving after receiving care. The story says his family had travelled from Al-Jawf to reach the hospital. Those details describe Faid’s circumstances in Yemen. They do not turn the image into evidence about Gaza, nor do they justify omitting his identity and treatment when sharing it.
What the image can and cannot establish
A photograph can document the person and scene shown in its original context. Here, the caption and fact-check trace it to a named child, a hospital in Sanaa, and a date in December 2020. Reposting it with a Gaza caption changes what viewers are told about the photograph. The mistake is concrete: the place, date and identity attached to the repost conflict with the original caption and the image’s documented history.
The correction should remain specific. This photograph does not show a child in Gaza in 2024, and it cannot be used as visual evidence of conditions there at that time. But disproving the caption does not establish that no children in Gaza experienced hunger or malnutrition. Kashif’s review itself noted that Gaza health officials reported malnutrition-related deaths in March 2024. The question here is where this particular image was made, not whether every separate report about Gaza is true or false.
That distinction matters whenever a striking image is shared during a crisis. A viewer should be able to trace who appears in it, where it was made and when. For this photograph, the contemporaneous caption and two Kashif fact-checks provide those answers. The defensible conclusion is narrow: the image shows Faid Samim in Yemen in December 2020; its March 2024 reuse as a photograph of Gaza was misleading; and the erroneous caption should not be repeated.