According to the U.S. Justice Department, Mercurio planned to attack a church "in the name of ISIS"—meaning he sought to commit mass murder on behalf of the Islamic State terror group. Prosecutors stated that Mercurio intended to incapacitate his father with a metal pipe, seize his firearms, and use them to assault a local congregation. Days before the planned attack, Mercurio stood before an ISIS flag holding a knife and "pledged his allegiance" to the group, formally declaring loyalty to the terrorist organization. Federal Bureau of Investigation agents arrested Mercurio on April 6, 2024, the day before he planned to execute the massacre. Investigators searching his residence in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, recovered butane canisters, lighters, handcuffs, a knife, a machete, and his father's firearms.
Prosecutors stated that Mercurio created an online repository of pro-ISIS material in early 2023 to spread the terror network's ideology. Mercurio initially intended to travel abroad to assist the group, but he lacked the necessary resources and instead turned to organizing a domestic strike within the United States. According to the U.S. State Department, federal law prohibits individuals from knowingly providing material support or resources—including weapons, explosives, or personnel—to a designated foreign terrorist organization.