---
title: "Gaza Fighting Casualty Counts: What the Goldstone Record Can Establish"
description: "The mission did not verify a definitive civilian-to-combatant ratio. It said Israel’s non-cooperation prevented it from corroborating classifications; the report presents incident findings, not a universal casualty list."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/civilian-vs-combatant-ratios-correcting-the-gaza-record"
type: "resource-page"
locale: "en"
categories: ["The Goldstone Report: Errors, Retraction, and Lessons"]
---

# Gaza Fighting Casualty Counts: What the Goldstone Record Can Establish

*The mission did not verify a definitive civilian-to-combatant ratio. It said Israel’s non-cooperation prevented it from corroborating classifications; the report presents incident findings, not a universal casualty list.*

The Goldstone mission did not verify a definitive civilian-to-combatant ratio for those killed in the 2008–09 Gaza fighting. It said it could not corroborate the classifications because Israel did not provide its figures. Its report makes findings about specific incidents, not a complete independently verified list assigning every death to a category.

## What the report says about classification

Report [A/HRC/12/48](https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-190202/) describes the mission’s evidence and its limits. In his 2011 statement, [Goldstone wrote](https://hrvoices.org/document/reconsidering-the-goldstone-report-on-israel-and-war-crimes/) that the mission could not corroborate the number of civilians and combatants killed because Israel had not cooperated. He also said Israeli military totals were similar to figures Hamas had furnished, while noting Hamas might have an incentive to inflate its combatant count.

A death toll and a combatant classification are different measures. Any proposed ratio needs to identify who produced the figures, when they were compiled, which area and period they cover, and how they classify members of armed groups. Goldstone’s statement does not turn the mission’s incident-level research into a verified universal census.

## Use the figures with their definitions

The Human Rights Council’s follow-up committee assessed investigations, not casualty totals. Its report, [A/HRC/16/24](https://documents.un.org/access.nsf/get?DS=A%2FHRC%2F16%2F24&Lang=E&OpenAgent=), discusses proceedings concerning allegations from the mission report. The committee did not publish a definitive casualty breakdown.

The mission’s access constraints and evidence gathering are described in [the methodology page](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/methodological-flaws-reliance-on-hamas-monitored-witnesses). Goldstone’s later qualification is covered [here](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/the-deliberate-policy-myth-richard-goldstone-s-2011-retraction).

## Pages

- [The Goldstone Report: Mandate, Findings, and Controversy](/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/overview.md)
- [What Goldstone Changed His Mind About in 2011](/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/the-deliberate-policy-myth-richard-goldstone-s-2011-retraction.md)
- [How the Mission Gathered Evidence and Where Access Was Limited](/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/methodological-flaws-reliance-on-hamas-monitored-witnesses.md)
- [Israeli and Hamas Investigations After the Report](/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/israeli-military-investigations-the-role-of-the-military-advocate-general.md)
- [Lessons for International Fact-Finding](/resources/the-goldstone-report-errors-retraction-and-lessons/reforming-international-fact-finding-lessons-from-the-goldstone-report.md)

## Sources

- [un.org](https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-190202/)
- [hrvoices.org](https://hrvoices.org/document/reconsidering-the-goldstone-report-on-israel-and-war-crimes/)
- [documents.un.org](https://documents.un.org/access.nsf/get?DS=A%2FHRC%2F16%2F24&Lang=E&OpenAgent=)
