---
title: "How to Check Claims of Media Bias"
description: "Compare a report with its original sources, headline history and corrections. One error documents one report; a pattern requires a defined sample and consistent comparisons."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/resources/media-bias-against-israel-case-studies-and-patterns/overview"
type: "resource-page"
locale: "en"
categories: ["Media Bias Against Israel: Case Studies and Patterns"]
---

# How to Check Claims of Media Bias

*Compare a report with its original sources, headline history and corrections. One error documents one report; a pattern requires a defined sample and consistent comparisons.*

To assess a report about Israel, compare its headline and claims with the underlying records, then check whether the outlet corrected errors. A dated mistake can establish what was wrong in that story; a claim of recurring bias requires a defined sample and consistent criteria.

Start with the original article, not a screenshot or a summary of it. Save the publication time, headline, byline, captions and correction note. Separate facts the reporter confirms from claims attributed to officials or witnesses. A report that quotes a source has not necessarily verified that source’s claim.

## Track headline changes and corrections

On February 3, 2016, CBS changed a headline about a Jerusalem attack after Israel’s Foreign Ministry objected to wording that did not identify the attack. The [Jerusalem Post’s dated account](https://www.jpost.com/arab-israeli-conflict/amid-israel-protest-cbs-amends-biased-and-dishonest-terror-attack-headline-443721) records the headline dispute and amendment. Compare the first version with the current article and any correction: did the change clarify the event, and did the outlet explain it to readers? This example establishes a specific editorial change, not an outlet-wide pattern by itself.

Reuters’ published [journalistic standards](https://reutersagency.com/about/standards-values/) call for accuracy, fair treatment and correction of errors. Use an outlet’s own rules as a checklist: Is the actor named? Is an allegation attributed? Is a correction prominent enough to fix a misleading headline as well as the body text?

## Compare statements in their original context

When a report translates an official statement, check the original language, the translation and the surrounding passage. For example, WAFA’s English report of Mahmoud Abbas’s January 17, 2018 speech at an Al-Azhar conference quotes him saying he would pursue options but not terrorism or violence, and then records his criticism of the U.S. Jerusalem decision. Read the [dated WAFA account](https://english.wafa.ps/Pages/Details/92354) in full before judging a shortened quotation. Record whether a version is an official translation, a reporter’s translation or an interpreter’s transcript; differences between versions need that context before they can show a substantive change.

For casualty figures, identify who collected them, the reporting period and whether the number distinguishes civilians from combatants. For photographs, check the photographer, date, location and caption; a frame alone cannot establish who caused damage. For negotiation claims, distinguish a proposal from an agreement that leaders signed. The [negotiation record](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/media-bias-against-israel-case-studies-and-patterns/the-erasure-of-peace-offers-and-defensive-context) and [Gaza reporting checks](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/media-bias-against-israel-case-studies-and-patterns/the-gaza-casualty-loop-and-media-dissemination) provide examples.

## Test a pattern with a sample

To support a pattern claim, state which outlet, dates, topics and articles you sampled. Apply the same test to each story—for example, whether a headline names the initiating attack or whether casualty data is attributed beside the figure. Keep the articles and your coding notes so another reader can repeat the comparison. A clear finding about a bounded sample is stronger than an accusation based on one headline.

## Pages

- [Reporting Gaza: Sources, Images, and Access](/resources/media-bias-against-israel-case-studies-and-patterns/the-gaza-casualty-loop-and-media-dissemination.md)
- [Peace Proposals and the Context for Security Coverage](/resources/media-bias-against-israel-case-studies-and-patterns/the-erasure-of-peace-offers-and-defensive-context.md)

## Sources

- [reutersagency.com](https://reutersagency.com/about/standards-values/)
- [jpost.com](https://www.jpost.com/arab-israeli-conflict/amid-israel-protest-cbs-amends-biased-and-dishonest-terror-attack-headline-443721)
- [english.wafa.ps](https://english.wafa.ps/Pages/Details/92354)
