---
title: "Attorney General and Ministry Lawyers: The Proposed Changes"
description: "A January 2023 draft proposed political appointments for ministry lawyers, nonbinding advice, and ministerial control over courtroom representation. The draft was not enacted."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/reforming-israel-s-government-legal-advisors-and-attorney-general"
type: "resource-page"
locale: "en"
categories: ["Israeli Judicial Reform Debate 2023-2024"]
---

# Attorney General and Ministry Lawyers: The Proposed Changes

*A January 2023 draft proposed political appointments for ministry lawyers, nonbinding advice, and ministerial control over courtroom representation. The draft was not enacted.*

In January 2023, Justice Minister Yariv Levin proposed making ministry legal advisers political appointees and their opinions nonbinding on ministers. The draft also proposed that ministers and the government control their courtroom representation, including choosing separate counsel. These were proposals, not changes enacted that year.

## How government legal advice worked

Ministry legal advisers were civil servants selected through public tenders and professionally subject to the Attorney General. Their opinions set out the law governing ministry action. If a ministry disagreed in a contentious matter, it could ask the Attorney General to determine the government's legal position. The Attorney General's opinion bound government bodies unless a court ruled otherwise. The [Israel Democracy Institute's explainer](https://en.idi.org.il/articles/48989) describes the roles of ministry advisers and the Attorney General.

## What the draft proposed

The January draft would have made ministry advisers positions of trust selected politically and would have removed the binding force of their advice for ministers. It also proposed giving ministers and the government authority to select the legal position presented in court and to choose lawyers separate from the Attorney General's office. Levin argued that elected officials should not be constrained by legal positions taken by unelected advisers. The [proposal analysis](https://en.idi.org.il/articles/48013) describes the changes under discussion.

The draft did not become law in 2023. Knesset legal advisers also raised procedural concerns about a Knesset committee initiating legislation on the status of government legal advisers. The proposals should not be mistaken for one comprehensive enacted change to the Attorney General's powers.

## The Pinchasi precedent on government representation

In 1993, the Supreme Court addressed the Attorney General's authority in HCJ 4267/93, Amitai – Citizens for Good Governance and Integrity v. Government of Israel, commonly discussed alongside the Deri-Pinchasi cases. The Court treated the Attorney General's legal position as the government's position and entrusted representation of the state to that office; separate private counsel required the Attorney General's consent. An [Israel Law Review account of government attorneys](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/israel-law-review/article/abs/hired-guns-and-ministers-of-justice-the-role-of-government-attorneys-in-the-united-states-and-israel/4D853BA7FA33AF869AA86F7913282A42) discusses the precedent and the representation rule.

The precedent does not remove courts as the final interpreters of law. The proposed changes concerned the allocation of legal judgment inside the executive: who advises a minister, whether that advice binds, and who speaks for the government in court. The [constitutional framework overview](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/overview) connects this proposal to the separate appointment and review plans.

## Pages

- [Israel's Constitutional Framework and the Judicial Reform Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/overview.md)
- [The Reasonableness Amendment and the January 2024 Supreme Court Rulings](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-reasonableness-standard-debate-in-israeli-judicial-reform.md)
- [Who Should Choose Israel's Judges? The Judicial Selection Committee Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/reforming-israel-s-judicial-selection-committee-the-2023-2024-debate.md)
- [The Override Clause: Could a Knesset Majority Overrule the Supreme Court?](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-knesset-override-clause-and-israeli-judicial-power.md)
- [Protests, Reservists, and the 2023 National Cohesion Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/idf-reservist-protests-and-israel-s-national-security-debate.md)
- [Herzog's Mediation and the Economic Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-president-s-mediation-and-compromise-frameworks-in-israel.md)

## Sources

- [en.idi.org.il](https://en.idi.org.il/articles/48989)
- [en.idi.org.il](https://en.idi.org.il/articles/48013)
- [cambridge.org](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/israel-law-review/article/abs/hired-guns-and-ministers-of-justice-the-role-of-government-attorneys-in-the-united-states-and-israel/4D853BA7FA33AF869AA86F7913282A42)
