---
title: "Israel's Constitutional Framework and the Judicial Reform Debate"
description: "Israel's constitutional rules come from Basic Laws and Supreme Court decisions, rather than one consolidated constitution. The 2023 proposals addressed judicial review, appointments, override powers, and government legal advice."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024"
type: "resource-page"
locale: "en"
categories: ["Israeli Judicial Reform Debate 2023-2024"]
---

# Israel's Constitutional Framework and the Judicial Reform Debate

*Israel's constitutional rules come from Basic Laws and Supreme Court decisions, rather than one consolidated constitution. The 2023 proposals addressed judicial review, appointments, override powers, and government legal advice.*

Israel's 2023 judicial reform debate concerned the limits on government power and who sets them. Israel has no single, consolidated written constitution: Basic Laws enacted by the Knesset and Supreme Court decisions form its constitutional framework. Proposals in 2023 would have changed judicial review, judge selection, the Knesset's ability to override court rulings, and the role of government legal advisers.

## How Basic Laws gained constitutional status

The Knesset adopted Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty in 1992. In [United Mizrahi Bank v. Migdal Cooperative Village](https://versa.cardozo.yu.edu/opinions/united-mizrahi-bank-v-migdal-cooperative-village), decided November 9, 1995, the Supreme Court held that the Knesset's Basic Laws form a higher legal framework and that courts can review ordinary legislation against protected rights. Israel's constitutional structure grew through separate Basic Laws instead of a single document. [Basic Law: The Judiciary](https://m.knesset.gov.il/EN/activity/documents/BasicLawsPDF/BasicLawTheJudiciary.pdf) sets out the judicial system and the process for appointing judges.

## What the government proposed

Justice Minister Yariv Levin announced a package in January 2023. Its central proposals included changing the Judicial Selection Committee, limiting the use of reasonableness review, creating a broad override power, and changing the authority of ministry legal advisers. They had different legislative paths: the Knesset enacted a reasonableness amendment on July 24, 2023; the other principal proposals did not become law that year. The [reasonableness amendment and Supreme Court rulings](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-reasonableness-standard-debate-in-israeli-judicial-reform) explain the enacted measure.

The proposed appointment changes would have altered who held seats and how many votes were needed to select judges. The [Judicial Selection Committee debate](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/reforming-israel-s-judicial-selection-committee-the-2023-2024-debate) follows the distinct drafts. A separate March bill proposed allowing 61 Knesset members to shield laws from judicial review; details appear in the [override clause account](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-knesset-override-clause-and-israeli-judicial-power). Proposed changes to legal advisers and courtroom representation are covered [here](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/reforming-israel-s-government-legal-advisors-and-attorney-general).

The public response included recurring demonstrations and reservists announcing pauses in voluntary service; the [protests and reservists page](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/idf-reservist-protests-and-israel-s-national-security-debate) explains what the reported figures counted. President Isaac Herzog also proposed a negotiated framework; read about [his outline and the Bank of Israel’s market reports](https://hasbara.co.il/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-president-s-mediation-and-compromise-frameworks-in-israel).

## Why the institutional checks mattered

Supporters said elected officials needed more authority over policy and appointments, and that judges held too much influence without direct electoral accountability. Opponents pointed to Israel's parliamentary system: a governing coalition normally controls both the cabinet and a Knesset majority, making judicial review and independent legal advice important checks on executive action. The dispute concerned how to balance electoral authority with legal limits.

On January 1, 2024, the Supreme Court held by 12–3 that it could review Basic Laws in exceptional cases and, by 8–7, voided the reasonableness amendment. The [Court's judgment](https://versa.cardozo.yu.edu/opinions/movement-quality-government-v-knesset) describes the rulings and their separate vote counts.

## Pages

- [The Reasonableness Amendment and the January 2024 Supreme Court Rulings](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-reasonableness-standard-debate-in-israeli-judicial-reform.md)
- [Who Should Choose Israel's Judges? The Judicial Selection Committee Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/reforming-israel-s-judicial-selection-committee-the-2023-2024-debate.md)
- [The Override Clause: Could a Knesset Majority Overrule the Supreme Court?](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-knesset-override-clause-and-israeli-judicial-power.md)
- [Attorney General and Ministry Lawyers: The Proposed Changes](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/reforming-israel-s-government-legal-advisors-and-attorney-general.md)
- [Protests, Reservists, and the 2023 National Cohesion Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/idf-reservist-protests-and-israel-s-national-security-debate.md)
- [Herzog's Mediation and the Economic Debate](/resources/israeli-judicial-reform-debate-2023-2024/the-president-s-mediation-and-compromise-frameworks-in-israel.md)

## Sources

- [versa.cardozo.yu.edu](https://versa.cardozo.yu.edu/opinions/united-mizrahi-bank-v-migdal-cooperative-village)
- [m.knesset.gov.il](https://m.knesset.gov.il/EN/activity/documents/BasicLawsPDF/BasicLawTheJudiciary.pdf)
- [versa.cardozo.yu.edu](https://versa.cardozo.yu.edu/opinions/movement-quality-government-v-knesset)
