---
title: "Joshua Angrist and Natural Experiments"
description: "Angrist and Victor Lavy used Israel’s 40-pupil class-size cap to estimate effects on test scores. Their 1999 study found gains for fourth and fifth graders, but not third graders; it was one example of causal research using natural variation."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/joshua-angrist-and-hebrew-university-s-nobel-legacy"
type: "resource-page"
locale: "en"
categories: ["Hebrew University of Jerusalem: Nobel Prize Factory"]
---

# Joshua Angrist and Natural Experiments

*Angrist and Victor Lavy used Israel’s 40-pupil class-size cap to estimate effects on test scores. Their 1999 study found gains for fourth and fifth graders, but not third graders; it was one example of causal research using natural variation.*

Joshua Angrist and Victor Lavy used Israel’s class-size rule to estimate how class size affected student test scores. The rule capped classes at 40 pupils, creating an enrollment pattern researchers could use to study cause and effect. Their 1999 study found gains from smaller classes for fourth and fifth graders, but not third graders.

## Turning the 40-pupil cap into a research design

Under the rule, a grade enrollment just above a multiple of 40 could trigger an additional class. As a result, the relationship between enrollment and class size changed at those thresholds. Angrist and Lavy used the discontinuity to construct instrumental-variable estimates, applying regression-discontinuity logic to the class-size question.

Their results were specific to the grades and schools studied. The estimates showed a significant and substantial increase in test scores for fourth and fifth graders when class size fell, while the same effect was not found for third graders. [The study record](https://cris.huji.ac.il/en/publications/using-maimonides-rule-to-estimate-the-effect-of-class-size-on-sch/) gives the method and grade-level findings. It does not establish that smaller classes produce the same gains in every school system.

## From Hebrew University to the Nobel Prize

Angrist served as a senior lecturer and associate professor in Hebrew University’s economics department during the 1990s. In 2021, he shared the economics prize with Guido Imbens for methodological contributions to the analysis of causal relationships. David Card received the other half for empirical contributions to labor economics.

The prize honored more than one Israeli education study: it recognized Angrist and Imbens’s broader methods for drawing conclusions from natural experiments. [The Nobel announcement](https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2021/press-release/) explains their contribution and why natural experiments can answer causal questions. [Hebrew University’s account](https://en.huji.ac.il/news/hebrew-university-congratulates-former-faculty-member-joshua-angrist-winning-nobel) records Angrist’s former faculty connection.

## Pages

- [Hebrew University and Its Nobel Laureates](/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/overview.md)
- [Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky, and Behavioral Economics](/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/roots-of-behavioral-economics-daniel-kahneman-at-hebrew-university.md)
- [Robert Aumann and Game Theory in Jerusalem](/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/robert-j-aumann-and-jerusalem-s-center-for-rationality.md)
- [Hebrew University Researchers in Chemistry and Medicine](/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/hebrew-university-alumni-and-the-ubiquitin-nobel-prize.md)
- [David Gross and the Strong Force](/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/theoretical-physics-excellence-nobel-laureate-david-gross.md)
- [Mathematics at Hebrew University: Abel and Fields Medal Work](/resources/hebrew-university-of-jerusalem-nobel-prize-factory/fields-medal-and-abel-prize-heritage-in-jerusalem.md)

## Sources

- [cris.huji.ac.il](https://cris.huji.ac.il/en/publications/using-maimonides-rule-to-estimate-the-effect-of-class-size-on-sch/)
- [nobelprize.org](https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2021/press-release/)
- [en.huji.ac.il](https://en.huji.ac.il/news/hebrew-university-congratulates-former-faculty-member-joshua-angrist-winning-nobel)
