---
title: "Fact check: Oslo II called for gradual transfers of specified powers in Area C, reserved permanent-status issues for negotiations, and preserved Israel’s authority over security and public order."
description: "Oslo II called for gradual transfers of specified powers in Area C, reserved permanent-status issues for negotiations, and preserved Israel’s authority over security and public order. It did not mandate a complete, automatic handover by 1999."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/facts-myths/oslo-ii-did-not-mandate-full-area-c-transfer-by-1999"
type: "fact-check"
locale: "en"
published: "2026-11-17T07:00:00.000Z"
updated: "2026-11-22 17:42:49"
categories: ["Legal", "Historical"]
---

# Fact check: Oslo II called for gradual transfers of specified powers in Area C, reserved permanent-status issues for negotiations, and preserved Israel’s authority over security and public order.

*Oslo II called for gradual transfers of specified powers in Area C, reserved permanent-status issues for negotiations, and preserved Israel’s authority over security and public order. It did not mandate a complete, automatic handover by 1999.*

## Myth

The Oslo Accords legally mandated that all of Area C in Judea and Samaria transfer automatically to Arab Settlers Authority civil and security control by 1999.

## Fact

Oslo II called for gradual transfers of specified powers in Area C, reserved permanent-status issues for negotiations, and preserved Israel’s authority over security and public order. It did not mandate a complete, automatic handover by 1999.

The claim that the Oslo Accords required all of Area C to pass automatically to Arab Settlers Authority civil and security control by 1999 misstates the 1995 agreement. Oslo II set out phased transfers of specified powers, left permanent-status questions for negotiation, and explicitly kept Israel responsible for security and public order in Area C.

## What the agreement says about Area C

Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization signed the Israeli-PLO Interim Agreement, commonly called Oslo II, on September 28, 1995. Its stated framework divided responsibilities during an interim period while the sides pursued a permanent arrangement. The [Oslo II civil-affairs annex](https://www.peaceagreements.org/agreements/985/) defines the transfer in Area C as gradual: powers unrelated to territory were addressed in the first redeployment phase, while territorial powers were to move in later phases, subject to matters reserved for permanent-status negotiations.

That language describes a process and specified areas of authority, not an automatic transfer of the entire territory. The same article says the Council would exercise functional jurisdiction only over powers actually transferred. It also says those transfers would not affect Israel’s continued authority over internal security, public order, and powers that remained untransferred. The claim therefore combines two errors: it treats a gradual transfer of defined responsibilities as a wholesale transfer of civil jurisdiction, and it says security control would transfer despite the agreement’s express reservation.

Oslo II also distinguished territorial jurisdiction from sovereignty. The agreement created interim governing arrangements; it did not settle the final borders or status of Area C. Questions reserved for the permanent-status negotiations were outside the transfer clause. The text thus cannot support a claim that the entire area’s future had already been decided by an automatic deadline.

## The timetable was not a blanket 1999 handover

The five-year interim period helps explain why 1999 appears in accounts of Oslo. The [U.S. State Department’s Office of the Historian](https://history.state.gov/milestones/1993-2000/oslo) describes the 1993 Oslo framework as establishing an authority that would assume governing responsibilities over five years, followed by permanent-status talks on borders, refugees, and Jerusalem. That broad framework set no single transfer date for every area or category of authority.

The detailed text set different steps and conditions. In Area C, early transfers covered powers not related to territory. Further redeployments were to proceed in stages, and the agreement’s civil-affairs provisions tied particular responsibilities to those phases. Israel’s security responsibilities remained in place even where civil functions were transferred. The deadline for completing the interim period did not erase these distinctions or convert them into an unconditional transfer of all territory and authority.

The sequence on the ground also shows why “automatic by 1999” is misleading. Norway’s Foreign Ministry, a participant in the diplomatic process, records that the 1999 Sharm el-Sheikh Memorandum scheduled a transfer of 7 percent from Area C to Area B on September 5, 1999, and a later transfer of 1 percent from Area C to Area A on January 20, 2000. It describes further redeployments, not a complete handover. The memorandum also set September 13, 1999, as the start of final-status negotiations.

## Transfers of powers did not settle final status

The accord’s design separated interim administration from the permanent agreement. The [Norwegian government’s account of the peace process](https://www.regjeringen.no/en/documents/involvement/id420034/?regj_oss=190) explains that the Oslo Declaration established stages and a timetable toward a permanent arrangement. It notes that the later Sharm el-Sheikh schedule included limited redeployments between the area categories, while final-status negotiations were to address the unresolved issues.

This distinction matters because a civil responsibility can be transferred without transferring sovereignty or every security power over the surrounding area. Oslo II made precisely that kind of division: the Council received particular functions as they were transferred, while Israel retained security and public-order authority in Area C. Neither the wording of the agreement nor the later implementation schedule says that all of Area C automatically became subject to the Council’s civil and security control in 1999.

The accurate account is narrower than either maximalist reading: Oslo II contemplated gradual transfers of certain powers in Area C during an interim arrangement, but exempted permanent-status matters and preserved Israel’s security authority. The agreement established negotiations and staged responsibilities; it did not predetermine a complete 1999 handover.

## Sources

- [peaceagreements.org](https://www.peaceagreements.org/agreements/985/)
- [history.state.gov](https://history.state.gov/milestones/1993-2000/oslo)
- [regjeringen.no](https://www.regjeringen.no/en/documents/involvement/id420034/?regj_oss=190)
