---
title: "Fact check: Hamas made a public claim after the attack that its fighters sought to avoid civilian harm, but this does not prove protective orders existed."
description: "Hamas made a public claim after the attack that its fighters sought to avoid civilian harm, but this does not prove protective orders existed. Investigations and video evidence document deliberate killings and hostage-taking of Israeli civilians."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/facts-myths/hamas-did-not-order-fighters-to-protect-israeli-civilians"
type: "fact-check"
locale: "en"
published: "2026-11-17T07:00:00.000Z"
updated: "2026-11-22 17:58:08"
categories: ["Military", "Political"]
---

# Fact check: Hamas made a public claim after the attack that its fighters sought to avoid civilian harm, but this does not prove protective orders existed.

*Hamas made a public claim after the attack that its fighters sought to avoid civilian harm, but this does not prove protective orders existed. Investigations and video evidence document deliberate killings and hostage-taking of Israeli civilians.*

## Myth

Hamas combatants who carried out the October 7 attacks were under strict orders from their leaders to protect Israeli civilians and avoid harming women and children.

## Fact

Hamas made a public claim after the attack that its fighters sought to avoid civilian harm, but this does not prove protective orders existed. Investigations and video evidence document deliberate killings and hostage-taking of Israeli civilians.

Hamas combatants who carried out the October 7 attack were not shown to have received strict orders to protect Israeli civilians. The claim reverses the record: Hamas issued its public denial months after its fighters attacked homes, killed civilians and seized hostages. Human Rights Watch and visual evidence it reviewed documented deliberate attacks across southern Israel.

## Hamas’s denial came after the assault

On January 21, 2024, Hamas’s Media Office published “Our Narrative—Operation Al-Aqsa Flood.” The [Times of Israel](https://www.timesofisrael.com/against-all-evidence-hamas-claims-to-oppose-harming-women-and-children/) reported the document’s assertion that avoiding harm to civilians, especially women, children and older people, was a moral and religious commitment of the Qassam Brigades. The document also said any civilian deaths had been accidental or occurred during confrontations with Israeli forces.

That was a statement of public justification, issued more than three months after the attack. It does not establish that commanders gave such instructions before or during the operation. Nor does a later assertion that fighters tried to spare civilians prove the existence of operational orders. The item’s specific claim—that attackers operated under strict protective orders—adds a detail Hamas’s public document alone cannot substantiate.

The distinction matters. Hamas’s account was not an order recovered from the attack’s chain of command. It was a retrospective explanation by the organization whose armed wing led the assault. Assessing it requires comparing the claim with what happened at the attacked communities and with the evidence gathered there.

## Evidence records deliberate attacks on civilians

[Human Rights Watch](https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/07/17/questions-and-answers-hamas-led-armed-groups-october-7-2023-assault-israel) interviewed 94 survivors and 50 other people, including relatives, first responders, medical experts and local officials. Its investigators analyzed more than 280 photographs and videos, alongside witness accounts. HRW said the material showed fighters seeking out civilians and killing them from the first moments of the assault, supporting its finding that civilian killing and hostage-taking were planned and coordinated.

The investigation describes attacks on people in their homes, in public shelters, on roads and in open areas. Fighters used rifles and grenades; in some homes they set fires to force people out of safe rooms. HRW documented killings, abductions, looting, mistreatment and hostage-taking. Its findings cover acts by Hamas’s Qassam Brigades and other armed groups that participated. The evidence is incompatible with a general operational policy to keep Israeli civilians safe.

Evidence includes footage made by attackers themselves, surveillance recordings and survivor testimony. The [Times of Israel’s account](https://www.timesofisrael.com/against-all-evidence-hamas-claims-to-oppose-harming-women-and-children/) described Hamas-recorded footage of attacks on homes, shootings, grenades thrown into safe rooms and civilians abducted. HRW’s investigation likewise found that attackers deliberately killed civilians and took hostages. These records describe actions, not merely harm that might have occurred accidentally in combat.

## Captured plans and public claims are different evidence

The Israeli military reported that materials collected from attackers included detailed plans for communities near the Gaza perimeter, operational documents and instructions concerning civilians. Its [October 16, 2023 statement](https://m.www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/idf-press-releases-israel-at-war/october-23-pr/evidence-of-hamas-plans-for-the-october-7-massacre-found-seized/) said the documents illustrated plans for an attack against civilians and soldiers and described the treatment and abduction of residents. This is an official Israeli account of captured materials; it should be read with that attribution. It does not turn every reported document into independently authenticated proof. But it directly contradicts the picture of a force whose defining instruction was to shield civilians from harm.

Hamas’s subsequent narrative also tried to shift responsibility for civilian deaths to chaos and Israeli forces. HRW’s interviews, images and verified videos instead documented fighters targeting civilians across multiple locations. The group’s own later explanation cannot erase those findings. A political movement can describe its ideals after an attack; that description does not override conduct captured on video or corroborated by survivors.

There is a further difference between a narrow possibility and the sweeping claim. Individual fighters may have acted differently at different moments. That possibility cannot establish that Hamas leadership issued strict orders to protect civilians, and the documented attacks provide strong evidence against treating such an order as the operation’s policy. No verified pre-attack directive supporting the claim is identified by the sources cited here.

The accurate conclusion is clear: Hamas publicly claimed it sought to avoid civilian harm, but that later claim is not proof of protective orders. The record documents intentional attacks on Israeli civilians and hostage-taking as part of the October 7 assault. Calling those actions the product of strict civilian-protection orders turns Hamas’s post-attack denial into a fact the evidence does not support.

## Sources

- [timesofisrael.com](https://www.timesofisrael.com/against-all-evidence-hamas-claims-to-oppose-harming-women-and-children/)
- [hrw.org](https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/07/17/questions-and-answers-hamas-led-armed-groups-october-7-2023-assault-israel)
- [m.www.idf.il](https://m.www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/idf-press-releases-israel-at-war/october-23-pr/evidence-of-hamas-plans-for-the-october-7-massacre-found-seized/)
