---
title: "Fact check: New York City inspectors found an empty excavation containing dirt, tools and debris, and authorities reported no evidence of human trafficking."
description: "New York City inspectors found an empty excavation containing dirt, tools and debris, and authorities reported no evidence of human trafficking. The tunnel was unauthorized construction that caused structural safety problems."
url: "https://hasbara.co.il/facts-myths/chabad-brooklyn-tunnel-was-not-used-for-child-trafficking"
type: "fact-check"
locale: "en"
published: "2026-11-18T07:00:00.000Z"
updated: "2026-11-22 17:40:53"
categories: ["General", "Media"]
---

# Fact check: New York City inspectors found an empty excavation containing dirt, tools and debris, and authorities reported no evidence of human trafficking.

*New York City inspectors found an empty excavation containing dirt, tools and debris, and authorities reported no evidence of human trafficking. The tunnel was unauthorized construction that caused structural safety problems.*

## Myth

An unauthorized tunnel beneath Chabad-Lubavitch headquarters in Brooklyn was built for a child sex trafficking ring.

## Fact

New York City inspectors found an empty excavation containing dirt, tools and debris, and authorities reported no evidence of human trafficking. The tunnel was unauthorized construction that caused structural safety problems.

A tunnel discovered beneath buildings beside Chabad-Lubavitch’s world headquarters in Brooklyn became the subject of a viral antisemitic conspiracy theory alleging that it was built to traffic children. New York City inspectors found an unauthorized excavation that had destabilized nearby structures; their inspection found dirt, tools and construction debris, while authorities reported no evidence of human trafficking. The available record describes unlawful construction and a dispute over access to the synagogue, not a child trafficking operation.

## What inspectors found beneath 770 Eastern Parkway

The incident came to public attention on January 8, 2024, at the Chabad-Lubavitch complex at 770 Eastern Parkway in Crown Heights. The [News 12 report](https://bronx.news12.com/nyc-inspectors-identify-underground-tunnel-surrounding-crown-heights-synagogue-some-members-say-it-is-an-expansion) said city inspectors identified a tunnel about 60 feet long beneath an extension connecting buildings around the headquarters. The excavation had no city approval or permits. Inspectors found it empty except for dirt and tools, and reported stability problems affecting connected buildings. The city issued partial vacate orders for two buildings and a full vacate order for another.

The New York City Department of Buildings explained the safety response in a statement quoted by [Lead Stories](https://leadstories.com/hoax-alert/2024/01/fact-check-no-evidence-of-human-trafficking-in-tunnels-under-nyc-synagogue.html). Inspectors ordered emergency stabilization, restricted occupancy in parts of the affected buildings, and pursued enforcement over the illegal work. The stated concern was structural safety. The department’s press secretary also said the tunnel was empty apart from dirt, tools and workers’ debris.

That finding directly conflicts with posts portraying the tunnel as a hidden trafficking site. Authorities inspecting the excavation did not report finding children, victims, restraints or evidence of trafficking. The NYPD told Lead Stories that investigators found no evidence of human trafficking and were not pursuing such charges. Police records instead concerned the confrontation that followed efforts to close the tunnel, including allegations such as criminal mischief, reckless endangerment and obstructing government administration.

## How a construction dispute became a trafficking rumor

The tunnel’s purpose became entangled with a long-running dispute inside the Chabad community over expansion of the crowded synagogue space and control of buildings around its headquarters. News 12 reported that some community members described the excavation as the beginning of an expansion of prayer space. Chabad’s spokesperson characterized the work as unauthorized and attributed it to a group of young men. These competing explanations concern why the excavation was made; neither establishes trafficking.

As [FactCheck.org](https://www.factcheck.org/2024/01/what-we-know-about-the-brooklyn-synagogue-tunnel/) reported, the tunnel did not cross Kingston Avenue to the Jewish Children’s Museum, despite online rumors suggesting a connection. The city’s diagram of the excavation showed the tunnel under adjacent buildings, not extending beneath the museum. That distinction matters because viral posts linked the tunnel to nearby children’s facilities as though proximity proved a criminal purpose. It did not.

Some posts also presented a mattress seen in video as evidence of abuse inside the tunnel. FactCheck.org traced the mattress to a space behind wood paneling and an exterior wall inside the synagogue, not to the excavation. A lawyer for the building said it had been placed there as support and padding for the thin paneling. The city described the tunnel itself as containing dirt, tools and debris. The online imagery therefore did not show trafficking evidence recovered from the tunnel.

## What the public record supports

The documented sequence is specific: an unauthorized excavation was discovered; the city investigated its effect on the buildings; inspectors found structural problems and ordered safety measures; and a confrontation occurred when workers moved to close the tunnel. Nine people were arrested in connection with that confrontation, while others received summonses. The reported charges related to conduct during the dispute, not child trafficking. The [NYPD statement and charge information reported by Lead Stories](https://leadstories.com/hoax-alert/2024/01/fact-check-no-evidence-of-human-trafficking-in-tunnels-under-nyc-synagogue.html) offer no basis for converting those arrests into proof of a trafficking ring.

FactCheck.org likewise concluded that there was no evidence that human trafficking was happening in the tunnel. Its account drew on information from New York City’s building department and the NYPD, alongside reporting on the physical layout and the misleading mattress video. News 12 independently reported the city’s inspection findings: an empty tunnel, construction tools and dirt, and building instability caused by the excavation. These sources address the claim with evidence about the site and the official response.

The rumor turned an illegal, dangerous excavation and a public altercation into an accusation of organized child abuse. The city’s findings and police response do not support that accusation. The tunnel was real; the trafficking story attached to it was not established by evidence from the site or by the authorities who investigated it.

## Sources

- [bronx.news12.com](https://bronx.news12.com/nyc-inspectors-identify-underground-tunnel-surrounding-crown-heights-synagogue-some-members-say-it-is-an-expansion)
- [leadstories.com](https://leadstories.com/hoax-alert/2024/01/fact-check-no-evidence-of-human-trafficking-in-tunnels-under-nyc-synagogue.html)
- [factcheck.org](https://www.factcheck.org/2024/01/what-we-know-about-the-brooklyn-synagogue-tunnel/)
